Quick answer
Send a connection request to most people you want to reach on LinkedIn, and put your effort into the first message after they accept. Save InMail for a short list of people who won't accept a stranger: Sales Navigator gives 50 credits a month, Premium Business 15 and Premium Career 5, and a credit only comes back if the person responds within 90 days. Use cold email for reach: there's no platform cap, and the average reply rate in Instantly's 2025 data was 3.43%. No large public benchmark isolates InMail's reply rate, so be careful with any single InMail number. For most B2B lists, the best setup is all three on the same people, in one sequence. LinkedIn's rules checked on 14 October 2026.
InMail vs connection request vs cold email at a glance
I build outbound for B2B companies on email and LinkedIn together, so all three of these end up on the same list in my campaigns. Here's how they differ, from LinkedIn's own help pages.
| InMail | Connection request | Cold email | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Who you can reach | Members you're not connected to | Anyone you can invite | Anyone with a verified work email |
| Monthly allowance | 50 credits on Sales Navigator, 15 on Premium Business, 5 on Premium Career | No published number. Notes are capped on free accounts | No platform cap. 20 to 30 a day per mailbox is a safe pace |
| Length | 200-character subject, 2,000-character body | 200-character note, optional | As long as you like. 30 to 40 words works |
| Follow-up | No second InMail until they respond | Free messages once they accept | As many steps as your sequence has |
| What it costs | Comes with a paid seat. You can't buy extra credits on Sales Navigator | Free | Domains, mailboxes, data and a sending tool |
| Main risk | Spending scarce credits on the wrong people | Invitation limits and restrictions | The spam folder and burned domains |
| Best for | Senior people who ignore strangers | Most people you want to talk to on LinkedIn | Volume, testing offers, people who aren't active on LinkedIn |
What the reply data says, and what it doesn't
Three numbers get quoted in every version of this comparison. Here's what each one counts:
| Source | What it divides | Result |
|---|---|---|
| Expandi, 13.2 million connection requests, May 2025 to April 2026 | Accepted requests by requests sent | 28.5% |
| Expandi, same data | Replies to the connection note by requests sent | 3.0%, down from 3.5% to 2.2% over the year |
| Expandi, 6.7 million outbound messages | Replies to outbound messages by messages sent | 10.4% |
| Instantly, cold email, 1 January to 18 December 2025 | All replies, follow-ups included, by emails sent | 3.43% average, 5.5% top quarter, 10.7%+ top 10% |
The 10.4% is the one people misread. It often gets quoted as the reply rate to the message you send after someone accepts, or as an InMail rate. It's neither. Expandi's "outbound messages" include welcome messages, follow-ups, group messages, event messages, InMails and emails, all pooled into one number. Expandi doesn't report InMail or email on their own.
LinkedIn doesn't publish an average InMail reply rate for sales seats either. Sales Navigator does track an InMail response rate on your seat, and free messages count toward it too. So if you see "InMail gets 18 to 25% replies" somewhere, ask where the number comes from.
What the data does support: the connection note rarely starts the conversation, and replies to notes are falling. The messages that follow do more of the work.
InMail: the rules that decide how you use it
InMail lets you message a LinkedIn member you're not connected to. You need a paid plan, and each plan comes with a monthly allowance (LinkedIn help):
| Plan | Credits a month | Most you can bank |
|---|---|---|
| Premium Career | 5 | 15 |
| Premium Business | 15 | 45 |
| Sales Navigator (Core, Advanced, Advanced Plus) | 50 | 150 |
The rules that change how you spend them:
- Credits come back only on a response. An InMail that is accepted, declined or answered within 90 days returns its credit. On Sales Navigator, "Not interested" and auto replies count too. An InMail that's ignored costs you the credit.
- One shot per person. You can't send a second InMail to someone until they respond to the first. There's no InMail follow-up sequence.
- No top-ups. Sales Navigator's help page says you can't buy extra credits, and carried-over credits must be used within 90 days.
- Some InMails are free. Messages to members with an Open Profile don't use a credit, though LinkedIn limits how many you can send in a given period. Free and basic accounts can send a limited number each month too.
- Credits don't travel. Premium credits can't be used in Sales Navigator, and your balance goes to zero if you cancel.
Fifty credits is about two a working day. That's a channel for named accounts, not for a list. I go deeper on spending them in Sales Navigator InMail credits: how many you get.
An InMail worth a credit gives a real reason in the subject and asks one question:
Subject: "Your first 90 days as VP Sales"
"Hi Jonas, congrats on the new role at [Company]. New sales leaders usually look at pipeline coverage first, and often find outbound running on old lists. Is rebuilding outbound on your plan for this quarter, or is it set for now?"
Connection requests: free, with a capped note
A connection request costs nothing, and once someone accepts you can message them as often as the conversation allows. Two limits apply:
- The note. Up to 200 characters, and free accounts can add one to only a few requests a month. Premium removes the note cap. LinkedIn's own help pages disagree on the exact free number, which I cover, with who deserves a note, in how many connection notes a free LinkedIn account gets.
- The requests. LinkedIn doesn't publish a fixed weekly number, and accounts that push too hard get restricted, Premium included. More in LinkedIn daily limits: what gets you restricted.
At Expandi's 28.5% acceptance rate, about 7 in 10 people don't accept, so they never see your message. For those who do, send the first message within a day, while they still remember clicking accept:
"Thanks for connecting, Jonas. Quick one: with the new SDRs starting in Munich, are they working from lists the HQ team builds, or building their own?"
One question about them, no pitch. The pitch comes when they answer.
Cold email: reach without a credit meter
Cold email has no platform deciding how many new people you reach. Volume grows with mailboxes: a warmed mailbox can send 20 to 30 cold emails a day, and new domains need 3 to 4 weeks of warmup before they start. The cost is the setup: domains, mailboxes, data and a sending tool.
Against InMail, email wins on reach and on follow-ups. You can send three or four steps to the same person, while InMail gives you one until they answer. InMail wins where email struggles: it doesn't depend on domain reputation, it arrives with your profile attached and it reaches people you can't find a verified email for.
A first cold email that works is 30 to 40 words, one concrete problem, one concrete offer and one question:
"Hi Jonas, saw [Company] is hiring three SDRs in Munich. New SDR teams usually spend the first month building lists by hand. We hand them verified target accounts on day one. Worth a look?"
Great copy means nothing if it lands in spam, so the infrastructure comes first. For how email and LinkedIn compare as whole channels, see cold email vs LinkedIn outreach.
Which one to send to which prospect
InMail vs connection request
Send a connection request if the person is active on LinkedIn, you want to message them more than once, you want them to see your posts or you're out of credits.
Send an InMail if they're senior and unlikely to accept a stranger, they ignored your request, you need more than 200 characters to give a real reason or they have an Open Profile, which makes it free.
LinkedIn InMail vs cold email
Send cold email if your list runs to thousands of accounts, you have verified emails for most of it, you want to test offers fast and you sell where cold B2B email is allowed.
Send an InMail if you can't find a verified email, your sending domains are still warming up, the person clearly lives on LinkedIn or the account is worth one of your 50 credits.
Rule of thumb. Spend an InMail only on someone you'd be annoyed to lose. If you'd send the same message to 200 people, it belongs in email.
Running all three on one list
This is how I set it up for clients: email and LinkedIn run as one sequence on the same people, and a reply on either channel stops both. If you have Sales Navigator seats, InMail slots in as the fallback for your top accounts:
- Day 1, email. 30 to 40 words, one problem, one offer, one question.
- Day 2, connection request. Usually blank. Keep the capped notes for people who need a reason to accept.
- Within a day of acceptance, a LinkedIn message. One question about them, never a copy of the email.
- Day 4 to 5, email two. A new angle or something useful.
- About a week in, InMail for top accounts that haven't accepted. One message, a different angle from the email.
- A reply anywhere stops everything. Nobody should get "bumping this up" after answering you on LinkedIn.
Each channel does one job: email gives reach, the connection request opens a free channel and InMail gets you to the few people the other two can't.
Key takeaways
- InMail is scarce: 50 credits a month on Sales Navigator, 15 on Premium Business, 5 on Premium Career. A credit returns only if the person responds within 90 days.
- You get one InMail per person until they respond, and Sales Navigator doesn't sell extra credits. Messages to Open Profile members are free.
- Connection requests are free, but notes are capped on free accounts and LinkedIn limits how many requests you send.
- Expandi's 10.4% message reply rate pools welcome messages, follow-ups, InMails, group and event messages and emails. It isn't an InMail rate or a post-acceptance rate.
- Cold email has no platform cap and averaged 3.43% replies in Instantly's 2025 data. Use it for reach, and InMail for the few accounts email and requests can't reach.
FAQ
Is InMail better than a connection request?
Only for people who won't accept a stranger. A connection request is free and opens unlimited messaging once accepted. InMail costs a credit and gives you one message until they respond.
How many InMails do you get with Sales Navigator?
50 credits a month on Core, Advanced and Advanced Plus. Unused credits carry over up to 150, carried-over credits must be used within 90 days and you can't buy extra.
Do you get InMail credits back?
Yes, if the person accepts, declines or replies within 90 days of your InMail. On Sales Navigator, auto replies and "Not interested" count. Ignored InMails don't come back.
Is LinkedIn InMail better than cold email?
For a short list of senior people, often yes: it skips the spam folder and shows your profile. For anything above a few dozen people a month, cold email wins, because it has no credit cap and lets you follow up.
What is a good InMail reply rate?
There's no reliable public benchmark. LinkedIn doesn't publish one for sales seats, and Expandi's 10.4% message reply rate mixes InMails with welcome messages, follow-ups, group and event messages and emails. Track your own rate per campaign instead.
